City of the Soul : A Walk in Rome

by William Murray

Release Date: 04 February, 2003

Edition: Hardcover

Price:

More Info

A delightful walk through Rome.

J.Tom Cooper (gktemugen@aol.com), book reviewer for a radio network., May 5, 2004,
A wonderful banquet of Roman anecdotes
I reviewed the 2-CD version of this book for my radio network and found it delightful. I have been to Rome many times, but Mr. Murray's delightful blend of personal and family anecdotes merged perfectly with his description of some famous and some less famous parts of the city. His pleasant vocal narration and his obvious thorough knowledge of the city kept me interested through the entire book on CD. I found myself taking notes on each piazza or building he described so that I could go back and experience them again. It isn't your typical guidebook description, but it is a perfect companion to a conventional book on Rome. His personal anecdotes about his family, lovers and friends were a welcome bit of spice. I recommend it highly.

Not Much Soul Here

Before you read on, perhaps you should know where I'm coming from: I've spent a great deal of time in Rome and Sicily every year since 1994. William Murray's little book about Rome is part of Crown's Journeys series. It's worth perhaps a quick hour's read by someone who has never been to or read anything about Rome; i.e., if you know absolutely nothing about the Vestal Virgins, you'll find a very brief but informative paragraph about them. Tourists will not find the book helpful. Although the book has a 2003 imprint, there are many indications that the chapters are reprints. For example, Murray wrongfully says that the Villa Borghese is not open to the public, whereas it has been open to the public for more than a year; and he refers to the Holy Year as "looming," whereas it has long since ended. There is some anti-American sentiment: Murray suggests that if Rome had been turned over to American engineers, they would have demolished the forums and the Colosseum; yet he flatly contradicts himself with an anecdote about an American millionaire who wanted to buy and restore the Colosseum. (In actuality, anyone who has been to Rome can tell you that the Italians need no help in allowing the degradation of their monuments.) A quotation from William Wetmore Story does not identify Story, not even to indicate that he is one of the more notable permanent residents of the Protestant cemetery in Rome. While he tells us that Janet Flanner was his mother's dearest friend and lover, you'll have to go elsewhere to learn anything about Flanner's place in literary history. Beyond that reference to Flanner, Murray's family reminiscences are quaintly meandering and do little to reveal Rome as a city of the soul.